German Doctors Warn of Collapse as Coalition Pushes Day-One Sick-Note Rule

Intensive care physicians and family doctors are bracing for a winter crisis, warning that the federal government’s plan to scrap telephone sick notes and force employees to obtain a medical certificate from the first day of illness could overwhelm already strained practices.

Christian Karagiannidis, a leading intensive care specialist, said the coming winter months could push the health system to its limits under the additional patient load. The proposals have drawn fierce opposition from medical associations, unions, and even factions within the governing coalition.

Andreas Gassen, chairman of the National Association of Statutory Health Insurance Physicians, called the plan “nonsensical.” He argued it is irresponsible to funnel more patients into practices that are already running at capacity. Markus Blumenthal-Beier, head of the German Association of General Practitioners, predicted a “massive wave of bureaucracy” and overflowing waiting rooms. Regional doctor groups from Bavaria and Bremen joined the criticism, noting that the telephone sick note — introduced during the pandemic to relieve pressure — was a sound measure that now lacks any medical justification for its removal.

The data undermines the reform’s rationale. According to health insurers such as DAK and the company health insurance funds, telephone sick notes accounted for only 0.8 to 1.2 percent of all incapacity-for-work certificates in recent years. Experts classify the planned change as a purely symbolic political move.

Economists at the German Institute for Economic Research (DIW) warn of a boomerang effect: employees who have to visit a doctor on the first day of illness risk infecting others on public transport and in waiting rooms, potentially driving up absence rates. A YouGov survey found that 59 percent of the German public oppose requiring a doctor’s note from day one.

Cracks are appearing within the coalition government. Health Minister Warken and Union representatives, including Jens Spahn, defend the stricter rules as a necessary response to high sick-leave levels. However, SPD co-chairs Lars Klingbeil and Bärbel Bas announced they would review the plan, insisting that no one should be forced to drag themselves to a doctor when ill. Former Health Minister Karl Lauterbach also distanced himself, saying he would not have made that decision.

Union leaders are outspoken in their opposition. Ver.di chief Frank Werneke and DGB chairwoman Yasmin Fahimi denounce the reform as an expression of a culture of distrust toward employees. Employer associations, while broadly welcoming tighter rules, point out that companies will still be able to negotiate individual exceptions.

en | boerse | 69685724 |