Almonty's First Tungsten Cargo Sails From Busan, but the Real Test Is Still Ahead
Published on 11/16/2026 at 14:11 | Editorial boerse-global.deAlmonty has crossed a threshold few tungsten developers ever reach: Sangdong produced its first tungsten concentrate in September, and a first container was loaded in Busan for shipment after the quarter closed. The stock moved 8.5% higher on Friday. Yet the milestone answers only one question — whether the mine works — while leaving the harder ones about earnings quality and legal exposure wide open.
Two Buy Ratings, Two Different Convictions
Friday's analyst action captured that tension neatly. According to media reports, Stifel cut its price target from US$21 to US$18 while keeping its buy rating, a positive call with a visible caveat attached. Alliance Global, by contrast, reaffirmed both its buy recommendation and its US$26.25 target, describing the recent share-price weakness as a buying opportunity.
So the shared "buy" label conceals a meaningful gap. Both houses like the stock; their targets show they do not agree on what it is worth. Reading the unchanged rating alone misses the more cautious valuation sitting behind it — though no specific reason for Stifel's trim should be inferred from the reports.
A Quarter Driven by Tungsten Prices
The operating backdrop comes from the third quarter of 2026. Almonty attributed a sharp revenue jump to higher tungsten prices, which is where the company story meets the broader commodity theme. Revenue climbed 382% to C$41.9 million, a genuine expansion of the business rather than a shift in accounting values.
Should investors sell immediately? Or is it worth buying Almonty?
Profit needs a different lens. Almonty reported a net profit of C$50.2 million, but that figure included non-cash revaluation gains of C$47.9 million. Adjusted EBITDA came in at C$14.6 million. A headline surplus of that size is not automatically proof of operating earning power at the same scale — a distinction that matters more than the identical "buy" tags on two analyst notes.
Cash stood at C$1.15 billion at quarter-end, a separate layer of the analysis that substitutes neither for judging earnings nor for scrutinising legal obligations.
Contracts Cover the Output, Not the Earnings
On the marketing side, more than 90% of Phase I production from Sangdong is contractually committed, according to the company. That is a meaningful signal for offtake, but it is not the same as booked revenue or realised profit. Contract coverage and earnings quality answer different questions.
Timing deserves attention too: Almonty placed the first concentrate output in September and the container loading after the quarter closed. Investors weighing operating news against quarterly results should keep that sequence in mind.
Deutsche Rohstoff Puts a Number on Its Claim
The legal front carries its own weight. Deutsche Rohstoff has quantified the claims it is pursuing in Canada at roughly US$67 million, including 3.5 million conversion shares and the repayment of promissory note loans. Almonty disputes the validity of the debt instruments. Deutsche Rohstoff and Thomas Gutschlag reject Almonty's allegations and are claiming payments under those instruments. According to Almonty, the proceedings have been consolidated.
Almonty at a turning point? This analysis reveals what investors need to know now.
That claim is an assertion, not an adjudicated obligation — and it should be weighed on its own terms rather than folded into the production narrative.
What Would Actually Convince
The first production proof deserves attention, and so does the loading of that first container. Both should remain what they are: operational evidence, not a verdict on every quarter that follows. Higher tungsten prices, operating results and contracted output need to line up with one another. The gap between the two price targets shows how much room for interpretation remains in this valuation. What counts is not the volume of confidence but its economic foundation.
Ad
Almonty Stock: New Analysis - 16 November
Fresh Almonty information released. What's the impact for investors? Our latest independent report examines recent figures and market trends.
